Hi!
This comittie thing is good idea. But how would you like to manage it?
If i upload here a map, then discuss about it, and after?- I will repair and upload again?...
I think it could be good as MM project but a little another way. For example XX start to edit the map the whole part and upload it. And the YY download it and edit also a little, and after upload back. Next time XX or ZZ download, edit and upload again. After XX can edit again a little... Dont count which part to edit, the next mapmaker will repair if see something wrong or etc... (this is nearly same how the Remake is programable? :S)
I think to nobody can find or can make perfect map...
All maps has some defects, still the best maps also. We all know it. And there are the map topics where always post the critics;)
I disagree with deleting maps from remake. Maybe the maps should be changeable at the RC installing.(you could select which parts be installed)
There should be 3-4 categories.
-The most popular maps
-Hard maps
-Easy maps
-The ugliest
-original maps
-remade maps
bla bla bla
-
.
.
.
Or another possibiity: the lobbies connecting to a website where always the latest maps are there where everybody can, could upload his/her new maps/if i saw well somewhere it is in a topic/...etc
I think we can all agree that, currently, the Remake has too many maps.
Sorry but i disagree.
Lots of them are ugly and can be deleted
Most of ugly. But i think to all mistakes are posted in the map topics. so every mapmaker can repair his mapos. And many maps fitted and repaired or balanced, but not added.
I think for example if we start to commiting an original map, for example Across the desert, or Boarder River8P(until the reseting of the game counter of the maps,BR8P wasnt in the Top100), then the remade map won't be added. This two maps has tons of bad tiles/and unbalanced things also?/. But what will happen if the Community make committing? The maps will be nearly perfect, but i dont think will be added to the basic maps. If i see well there is a clan who always still play AtD fix0.4 and this isnt added version.
So i think the best if all players find his our way to refresh his map archive.
Anyway many maps looks out really good, but I've still not play on it and i cant tell you why?:S
Many bad tiles and other errors
i always would like to connect 3 other kind of tilesXD i always try to hide them with elevations;)
And i think to if the best players say this and this maps are unplayable, then not always should to beilive that, because those players not always playing other rules, or dont like other rules. For example long PT, shorter PT, faster gamespeed, only leather game, only iron game...etc.
So i like if the map list is enough long.
Everybody has a playing style, and everybody can find his "homeland";)